This week's New York Times Bestsellers (November 27th)

In hardcover:

Terry Goodkind's Confessor debuts at number 2. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Laurell K. Hamilton's A Lick of Frost is down two positions, ending its fourth week on the charts at number 17. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Clive Barker's Mister B. Gone is up two spots, finishing its third week on the NYT list at number 22. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

R. A. Salvatore's The Orc King is up one position, ending its eighth week on the bestseller list at number 24. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

In paperback:

Cormac McCarthy's The Road maintains its position at number 8. This marks the book's 33rd week on the prestigious bestseller list. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Karen Traviss' Star Wars: Republic Commando: True Colors is down five spots, finishing its second week on the charts at number 28. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Knights of the Black and White

I've been fascinated with the Knights Templar and their demise ever since watching a documentary on their order during my early teenage years. There is something about the Knights Templar that really captures one's imagination. As a matter of course, I read Holy Blood, Holy Grail, which then led me to order various related works such as The New Knighthood and The Trial of the Templars. Hence, long before The Da Vinci Code introduced them to mainstream readers, I was already intrigued by the mystery and mysticism shrouding the Order of the Temple. It was thus with great eagerness that I read Jack Whyte's first Templar novel.

Knights of the Black and White recounts the beginnings of the order. It's a tale about those nine penniless men who dug for years into the bowels of the Holy City of Jerusalem, and unearthed a treasure which allowed them to become the most influential force in Christendom for more than two centuries.

I really enjoyed how Whyte sets the stage at the start of the novel. Sir Hugh de Payens, a member of a secret society, learns the grave truth about the Order before being sent to fight in what history will remember as the First Crusade. But he emerges from the harrowing slaughter of Jerusalem as a broken man who has lost faith in his fellow knights.

Knights of the Black and White is an interesting blend of historical data and good storytelling. Anyone who has ever shown any interest in the Knights Templar should be pleased with the tale. Others might not find this book as appealing, however. . .

Whyte's narrative sets the mood, and his prose is evocative in a manner that creates the perfect imagery. There are a few info dumps along the way, most of them a necessary evil in a work such as this. What I found the most distracting was the author's tendency to switch from one POV character to the next in the same sequence, without even a break in the scene to signal a POV change.

The characterization is an aspect that leaves a little to be desired in some instances, and that was disappointing. Some characters are well-done; Hugh de Payens and Hassan the Shi'a come to mind. Yet others are clichéd and two-dimensional, characters such as Princess Alice, Brother Stephen St. Clair, and Bishop Odo.

Still, the storylines weave a satisfying tale, even though this first volume covers only the order's humble beginnings. It will be interesting to see where Jack Whyte takes his story in the sequel, Standard of Honor. Hopefully weak characterization will not put a damper on one's reading experience in the subsequent volumes.

As the opening chapter of a saga chronicling the birth and future destruction of an organization whose secrets echo down the centuries to tantalize us even today, Knights of the Black and White remains an entertaining read.

The final verdict: 7.25/10

For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe

Daniel Abraham's Symposium on Epic Fantasy: The setting

With Daniel dropping by and leaving comments on a number of posts, I realized that I completely forgot to link his latest report of that symposium of his.

Another interesting article which you can read here.

I'm curious to read future reports. . .:-)

J. V. Jones Interview

I'm aware that there was a lot of interest for this Q&A.

Many thanks to the folks at Tor Books and Julie for helping me to put this interview together.

So without further ado, here it is!;-)

Enjoy!
-----------------------

- Your newest title is one of the most eagerly awaited fantasy book of 2007. What is it about A Sword from Red Ice that made the novel more arduous to write than your previous books?

At one point A Sword From Red Ice became too big for me. I had ten point-of-view characters to write for, and while I was swapping between them I had a sense that I was losing focus. Raif, his brother, sister and clan, and Ash are the main subjects of the series, and I had to stop and refocus upon them. That meant cutting out characters who I was genuinely interested in and delaying their appearances until later in the series. Then I went back and restructured the book. This took time. However, the main reason why the book took so long is that I was developing as a writer. By the time I reached the final scene, the prologue and early parts of the book no longer reflected my experience as a writer. My work has, I hope, become leaner and more truthful. I’m glad I took the time to rewrite and revise: I think Sword is a better book because of it.

- What can readers expect from the subsequent two volumes of the series?

Readers should expect to learn more about the characters; what they are capable of under pressure and what has the power to break them. I love my characters, but it’s not a blind love. They have faults, terrible faults, and the rest of the series will reveal and highlight them. Subsequent books will offer chances for greatness, goodness, and redemption. At this point even I don’t know who will succeed and who will fail. As I writer I’m interested in the conflicts we carry in our hearts. We’re afraid, yet we act in face of that fear. We love passionately, yet we’re rarely selfless. Books IV and V will show Raif coming to terms with hard realities. How do you live a life when you’re cut off from your family, home and community? What is your responsibility when you can kill an enemy so effortlessly, from a distance, that you don’t have to look him in the eye?

- What are the main challenges that you will face as an author in order to finish the series the way you have always envisioned it?

The primary challenge for me is tell the truth. I’m writing Epic Fantasy and it’s a genre with strong traditions, and my focus is to keep the story pertinent. I don’t want the world and the characters to be archaic constructions that have no relation to how we live our lives today. I want readers to think,“Yes, I recognize this. I’ve felt like that. I’ve been in a situation where I had to make that choice.” The series is written on a large scale--countries, clans, continents, races--and my main challenge is to hold that scale in tension while telling the personal stories within it.

- What's the progress report on the fourth volume the Sword of Shadows saga? Any tentative title and release date yet?

I’m writing Book IV right now. If you attended World Fantasy in Saratoga you got a sneak preview of the Prologue, which I used for a reading. The book will be finished next year and I expect it to be published in 2009.

- What was the spark that generated the idea which drove you to write the Sword of Shadows in the first place?

I’ve always been fascinated with cold climates: arctic tundra, glaciers, sea ice, pine forests blanketed in snow. For me, cold and remote places are filled with wonder and possibility. I have a sense that mysteries lie beneath the ice, that if one were to fall through a fissure in a glacier one might find oneself in another world. The Sword of Shadows series started, quite simply, because I wanted to set a story in a bleak and windswept land.

- Characters often take on a life of their own. Which of your characters did you find the most unpredictable to write about?

The characters who are the most insecure are the least predictable. Ash, who is deeply insecure, is capable of great shifts in behavior. She’s missing the firm foundation of a family who loved her, and that makes her vulnerable. Oddly enough, the Dog Lord, Vaylo Bludd, never had a family who loved him either, but he has a strong sense of who he is. Ash is a lot younger and hasn’t developed that yet. Plus, she literally doesn’t know where she came from. The Dog Lord always knew he was an unwanted, illegitimate son. That sense of self, when present in a character, makes behavior more predictable. When it’s missing anything can happen.

- Have the plotlines diverged much since you began writing the series, or did you have the entire plot more or less figured out from the very beginning? Were any characters added or further fleshed out beyond your original intention? Have you made any changes to your initial plans during the course of the writing of the series?

I had a plot when I began, but I didn’t follow it. The characters shanghaied the story and I like it that way. I’m constantly surprised and entertained by the writing process as I’m never quite sure what will happen in a scene. The joy of writing for me is creating that scene, that chance for characters to interact and then allowing them to be themselves.
The Dog Lord is a character who wasn’t planned. One day I fancied a break from Blackhail’s storyline and brought him in. The same with Bram Cormac. Now I care about both of them very much. Other characters were already present in the story, such as Marafice Eye and Effie Sevrance, and after a while I chose to write for them, rather than about them. It’s all a bit spare-of-the-moment. As a writer, I want to challenge myself. Writing from different POVs is one of the ways I do that.

- What do you feel is your strength as a writer/storyteller?

I hope it’s my characters. I have a strong sense of them and never have to wonder what they’re likely to do in any given situation. They just go right ahead and do it.

- The fact that there are a website dedicated to your work is an indication that interaction with your readers is important to you as an author. How special is it to have the chance to interact directly with your fans?

http://www.jvj.com/ is one of the longest running writer websites on the internet. We’ve been going since 1994, a year before The Baker’s Boy was published. Back then, we didn’t have our own domain, just a very long URL and handful of bright blue hyperlinks. My brother Paul and I have run it, hands on, from the beginning. And from the very beginning readers have been able to contact me via email. This is important to me. Writing is a solitary profession. When things are going well you spend the entire day on your own. Contact is a lifeline. It reminds me why I write: I want to tell a good story and hopefully entertain someone for a while.

- Given the choice, would you take a New York Times bestseller, or a World Fantasy Award? Why, exactly?

Either would be nice.

- More and more, authors/editors/publicists/agents are discovering the potential of all the SFF blogs/websites/message boards on the internet. Do you keep an eye on what's being discussed out there, especially if it concerns you? Or is it too much of a distraction?

For the first four weeks after SWORD came out I regularly did searches for reviews, but apart from that I leave well alone. One can’t control what’s being written about oneself or one’s work so it’s best not to worry too much about it. For SF news I check locusmag.com and for book reviews I read publishersweekly.com and nytimes.com.

- Honestly, do you believe that the speculative fiction genre will ever come to be recognized as veritable literature? Truth be told, in my opinion there has never been this many good books/series as we have right now, and yet there is still very little respect (not to say none)associated with the genre.

Cormac McCarthy won the Pulitzer prize this year for The Road, which is SF. Right now the entire country is reading the magic realism of Gabriel Garcia Marquez’ Love in the Time of Cholera, as Oprah picked it this month for her book club. Speculative fiction is alive, well and much-honored. What’s not much honored is epic fantasy written in the tradition of Tolkien. I don’t see this changing any time soon. Just the word “fantasy” alone is enough to send the critics running. Why this is, I’m not sure. To a certain extent all “genres”--romance, westerns, epic fantasy, who dunits--are unfairly dismissed by the critics.

- It's said that there's a certain lack of respect from writers (non-speculative fiction) towards authors of genre fiction, especially female writers. Have you had to deal with any such problems and what are your thoughts on the subject?

I’ve been told many times that while women buy books by both male and female writers, men prefer to buy books by male writers. I’m not sure if this is true. I believe a book finds its audience through word-of-mouth, and a good book appeals equally to both men and women.

- Anything else?

I write the story I want to read. That’s my guiding principle as a writer. From an early age I was drawn to epic fantasy. The scale appeals to me, the idea that everything we hold precious depends upon the decisions of a handful of people. As a writer I’m playing with the highest possible stakes--if all goes well, life as we know it continues. If one key thing goes wrong it all ends. That’s exciting to me. It gives me chills and I hope to pass along those chills to my readers.

Calling on all Malazan and Wild Cards fans!


I've been approached by the cool folks at Dabel Brothers Publishing (http://www.dabelbrothers.com/) to help them get the fans involved in two projects they have on the way. As you know, they are the ones that will bring you The Malazan Book of the Fallen and the Wild Cards graphic adaptations. Above you can see a sketch of Whiskeyjack, one of the heroes from Steven Erikson's opus, as well as one of Croyd, a Wild Cards character.

They would like to know what sort of promotional material you guys would be interested in. They have been thinking about officially licensed prints of characters or scenes, shirts, or similar products. But they would like to know what the people who'll be purchasing the graphic adaptations would like to get their hands on.

That's where you guys come in!:-) Feel free to let everyone know what would scratch your itch. The Dabel Brothers are looking for ideas, so feel free to go all out!;-)

NFL Showdown: GRRM vs Pat (Week 12)

Dallas Cowboys 34
vs
New York Jets 3

Minnesota Vikings 41
vs
New York Giants 17

Well, the 'Boys are now 10-1 and the G-Men fell to 7-4. With two wins against the Giants and one win against the Jets this season, if that doesn't earn me a gruesome death if I win this wager, nothing will!:-)

But since the Cowboys have a history of screwing up late in the season, victory is not assured just yet. . .

THE WISE MAN'S FEAR news

We all knew that Patrick Rothfuss's sequel to his popular debut, The Name of the Wind, has been postponed. But no one knew just how delayed The Wise Man's Fear was going to be.

I contacted Betsy Wollheim a few days back, and here's what she revealed:

Pat will not be delivering the complete first draft until March, and I've only read a few tantalizing sections. We're hoping to publish in April '09. We're planning at least two rewrites.

I'm aware that most of you were hoping for a late 2008 release, but it appears that it's not to be. . . Having said that, I'm glad to see that Daw Books will not rush this one. They obviously want the sequel to live up to the expectations generated by its predecessor, and they will not be publishing a book which is anything less than Rothfuss' best effort.

To all you Toronto Maple Leafs fans. . .

This one's for you!;-)


Take that, haters!:p

Ian Cameron Esslemont's RETURN OF THE CRIMSON GUARD synopsis

From Amazon.co.uk:

The return of the mercenary company the Crimson Guard could not have come at a worse time for the Malazan Empire. Drained by constant warfare, weakened by betrayal and rivalries, many see the grip of Empress Laseen weakening. Conquered kingdoms and principalities test their old independence. Into this gathering civil war on Quon Tali - the Empire's homeland - comes the Guard. And with their return comes the memory of their hundred year old vow: undying opposition to the existence of the Empire. Yet, rivalries and betrayals stalk the Guard as well - elements of its elite, the Avowed, scheme to open paths to even greater power. Ancient potent entities, Ascendants, also lend a hand exploiting all sides to further their own arcane ends.Meanwhile, a swordsman, Traveller, and his companion Ereko, move from one strange encounter to another in a mysterious dance meant ultimately to bring the swordsman to a final confrontation from which none have ever returned. As the Crimson Guard gathers itself from around the globe, Empress Laseen faces more immediate threats. To feed her wars she has bled dry provincial garrisons across Quon Tali and now regional nationalists see their chance. Behind their insurrections stand the veteran commanders of Laseen's predecessor, Emperor Kellanved. These generals and powerful mages, the "Old Hands," have lost patience with what they see as Laseen's mismanagement and have selected their own replacement. Yet, there are hints that Laseen may be using the uprisings to draw out and finally eliminate these last irksome survivors of her predecessor's rule...

Ah, I can't wait!!!;-)

This week's New York Times Bestsellers (November 20th)

In hardcover:

Laurell K. Hamilton's A Lick of Frost is down six positions, ending its third week on the charts at number 16. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Clive Barker's Mister B. Gone is down four spots, finishing its second week on the NYT list at number 24. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

R. A. Salvatore's The Orc King is down two positions, ending its seventh week on the bestseller list at number 25. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Kristen Britain's The High King's Tomb debuts at number 29. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

In paperback:

Cormac McCarthy's The Road is up two spots, finishing its 32nd week on the prestigious list at number 8. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Karen Traviss' Star Wars: Republic Commando: True Colors debuts at number 23. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

The 5 new Malazan covers





Kind of makes you wonder what it was all for, doesn't it?

I'm not saying the book covers are atrocious, but I did prefer the originals. Are these any less generic, any less fantasy?

Food for thought. . .

I'll be damned. . .

Here's the synopsis for Paul Kearney's (www.paulkearneyonline.com) forthcoming The Ten Thousand:

The world of Kuf, an ancient Assurian Empire, dominant, prestigious and thought to be invincible, is about to be shaken to its very foundations. An exile from the empire, the Great King’s brother, hires a force of ten thousand elite mercenaries of a legendary race known as the Macht to take the throne by force. But when their employer is killed, the Ten Thousand find themselves abandoned. This is the story of their fight for freedom, and marks the start of a brand new series by one of the finest writers of fantasy around.

Mark Newton, one of the editors at Solaris Books (www.solarisbooks.com), emailed me about this yesterday. He knew I was a fan of Kearney, and thought I'd be interested in learning more about what Paul was working on.

Now, I've mentioned elsewhere how running this blog engendered quite a few "fuck me" moments since its creation. Newton's email was the latest of those. It turns out that he learned about Kearney's misfortune with Bantam Press and Bantam Dell from my "This really sucks" blog post from last May. A fan of the author, Newton contacted him and voilà! Paul Kearney signed with Solaris Books.

As a matter of course, I'm aware that my reviews, interviews, giveaways, etc, have had a positive influence on many writers' careers, and I'm delighted about that. I really am. And all I ask in return is a drink or two. Well Paul, if you're reading this, given the fact that you already owed by at least a drink, I figure that you now owe me a few. A pitcher, even, if I may be so bold!;-) Seriously, I'm really happy that my little rant about the unfairness of it all helped you find a new publishing home.

Hmmm, it occurs to me that I should stop dealing in booze from now on. . . At least with GRRM I had the presence of mind to ask to be murdered in the A Dance with Dragons. Maybe I should try to get myself killed in as many SFF novels as I possibly can. Think my mom would be proud of that!?!

Okay, so Kearney's misfortune really sucked. But to all you SFF editors out there, you want to know what really, really sucks!?! Well, the fact that I have yet to find a publisher myself! My agent Matt Bialer has two of my manuscripts, so someone step up to the plate and offer us a book deal, damn it!:p

Win a copy of THE SOLARIS BOOK OF NEW FANTASY

Thanks to the cool folks at Solaris, I have a couple of copies of their brand new anthology, The Solaris Book of New Fantasy, for you guys to win. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

The anthology is comprised of short stories by authors such as Janny Wurts, Hal Duncan, Jeff VanderMeer, Chris Roberson, Mike Resnick, Jay Lake, Steven Erikson, and more. It's a great line-up, and I'm curious to see how good it is.:-) For more information, check out www.solarisbooks.com.

The rules are the same as usual. First off, you need to send an email at reviews@(no-spam)gryphonwood.net with the header "SOLARIS." Remember to remove the "no spam" thingy.

Second, your email must contain your full mailing address (that's snail mail!), otherwise your message will be deleted.

Lastly, multiple entries will disqualify whoever sends them. And please include your screen name and the message boards that you frequent using it, if you do hang out on a particular MB.

Good luck to all the participants!

Help Raise Funds for Breast Cancer Research

Hi guys!

With the Holiday shopping just around the corner, I just wanted to remind everyone that all the proceeds from my Amazon Associates Program will by donated to the Canadian Breast Cancer Research Foundation. All you need to do is click on one of the links you can find in my reviews and other posts (Canada, USA, Europe), and a small percentage of all your purchases will be donated to that worthy cause.

Whether you're planning on buying books, CDs, DVDs, video games, an Ipod, a laptop, a plasma screen, or just a gift certificate, I invite everyone to shop through those links. I'm glad to announce that the test results are in, and there is no trace of cancer left in my mother's body!:-) Sadly, too many women cannot claim the same.

As I stated in September when Robert Jordan passed away, I will donate all the proceeds generated by the Amazon Associates Program till December 31st to the foundation. Hopefully, one day soon a cure for Breast Cancer will be found.

Until then, every single penny counts. So if you want to help make a difference, you guys know what to do!

Win an autographed Advance Reading Copy of GRRM and co.'s INSIDE STRAIGHT

Thanks to the kind folks at Tor Books (who are going all out for this giveaway!), I have two Advance Reading Copies of the newest Wild Cards novel, Inside Straight (Canada, USA, Europe), up for grabs. As if this wasn't enough, both ARCs will be signed by all nine authors, making these two prizes collector's items of great value! Each copy will hence bear the signature of George R. R. Martin, Daniel Abraham, Melinda M. Snodgrass, Carrie Vaughn, Michael Cassutt, Caroline Spector, John Jos. Miller, Ian Tregillis, and S. L. Farrell. Is that cool or what!?!;-)

The rules are the same as usual. First off, you need to send an email at reviews@(no-spam)gryphonwood.net with the header "STRAIGHT." Remember to remove the "no spam" thingy.

Second, your email must contain your full mailing address (that's snail mail!), otherwise your message will be deleted.

Lastly, multiple entries will disqualify whoever sends them. And please include your screen name and the message boards that you frequent using it, if you do hang out on a particular MB.

Good luck to all the participants!

P. S. GRRM sent me the 9-way Wild Cards interview yesterday, and it's going to be something! Stay tuned for that!:-)

Joel Shepherd contest winners!

Each winner will receive a complimentary copy of Joel Shepherd's intelligent and action-packed Killswitch (Canada, USA, Europe), courtesy of Pyr.

The winners are:

- Christopher Robbins, from Brigantine, New Jersey, USA

- John M. Lohman, from Traverse City, Michigan, USA

- Dave Wyatt, from Fukton, Maryland, USA

Thanks to all the participants!;-)

K. J. Parker contest winner!

Thanks to Orbit's generosity, our lucky winner will get his hands on all three volumes of K. J. Parker's The Engineer Trilogy; Devices and Desires (Canada, USA, Europe), Evil for Evil (Canada, USA, Europe), and The Escapement (Canada, USA, Europe).

The winner is:

- John D. Sill, from Round Lake, Illinois, USA (the pesky complainer known as Jaxom 1974 on asoiaf.westeros.org!)

Hmmm, I'm tempted to send him a Stanek set instead. . .:p

NFL Showdown: GRRM vs Pat (Week 11)

Dallas Cowboys 28
vs
Washington Redskins 23

New York Giants 16
vs
Detroit Lions 10

This from GRRM's Not A Blog:

I have a sick feeling in the pit of my stomach that we're headed toward a Cowboys - Patriots Superbowl. There's no teams I loathe more. I'll have no one to root for. Is there some way both of them can lose?

Unless the Cowboys choke, it looks as though a grisly death is in store for Patrick St. Denis. I think I'll kill a couple of guys named Romo and Teo along with him.

(Sits down to sharpen his axe).

He he he!;-) Music to my ears. . .
Still, the Giants are hanging in there and they continue to win. So we're not out of the woods yet. . .
But things are definitely looking up!

Special Subpress 50% off Sale

This from the Subterranean Press website:

This special is good until the end of the day on Tuesday, November 20, 2007.

Order at least 5 Limited or Trade editions priced $150 or less (in print or forthcoming books are eligible, but Lettered editions are not) and your total order is 50% off. To take advantage, you must mention this special when checking out. Your shopping cart and automatic email confirmation won’t refect the sale price, but don’t worry, we’ll catch it when processing your order. Limit of one copy of any given title.

A few other things to note. If paying via PayPal, do NOT go through our store. Drop us an email for a PayPal invoice. This special may not be combined with any other special offer, coupon, or savings certificate. Regular shipping charges apply.

Since forthcoming books are eligible, check out the new Gaiman, Erikson, GRRM, Novik, Morgan, etc, Bill and co. have on the way!;-) Check out www.subterraneanpress.com.

Dreamsongs, Volume 1

Before I begin this book review, I feel the need to point out the fact that I'm not the most conversant of readers when it comes to short fiction. I wish I could read more novellas and short stories, but SFF anthologies have seldom managed to really satisfy me. The main problem with anthologies is that they're too much like Beastie Boys albums (barring License to Ill), meaning that they habitually contain a couple of gems that are worth your while. And yet, inevitably, these gems are buried underneath lackluster and uninspired works, which naturally kills the anthology for me.

As was the case with the bulk of fantasy readers, I was a bit taken aback by the buzz surrounding Martin's A Game of Thrones when it was initially released. Like most, I was unaware of GRRM's award-winning body of work in terms of short fiction. To me, he was simply the "Wild Cards guy." Yes, in retrospect, I was an idiot. Incidentally, many contend that I still am, but I digress. . .

Hence, Dreamsongs appeared to be the perfect opportunity for me to get better acquainted with the material which allowed George R. R. Martin to win every possible speculative fiction award, or so it seems. But still I was reticent, wondering if this collection of short fiction was for me. Well, I'm sure glad I elected to give this one a shot!

As a compendium of GRRM's early work, Dreamsongs is a veritable journey through the author's long and celebrated career. Each section begins with an extensive and insightful commentary that permits us to learn quite a lot about the man and his stories. As good as the material is -- and believe me, anthologies don't get much better than this! -- I found Martin's commentary to be at times as fascinating as the tales themselves.

As a matter of course, detractors and haters will bitch and moan about the fact that, once again, this is not A Dance with Dragons, that GRRM is spending too much time working on various other projects instead of focusing on his bestselling series. In all honesty, this might not be the next ASOIAF installment, yet I believe that it's the next best thing. In many ways, I was more impressed by Dreamsongs than by what I've read thus far of the ASOIAF saga. This collection demonstrates just how talented and versatile an author GRRM truly is.

While some stories are better than others, I think that every piece which was selected to comprise this anthology belongs within its pages. Indeed, it allows the reader to grasp how GRRM's career and writing style evolved over the years. My favorites include The Exit to San Breta, The Second Kind of Loneliness, With Morning Comes Mistfall, A Song for Lya, The Way of Cross and Dragon, The Lonely Songs of Laren Dorr, Remembering Melody, and Nightflyers.

Only rarely does a book make such an impression on me. Truth to tell, I really feel like a dumbass for ever referring to GRRM as the "Wild Cards guy." I've been reading and appreciating speculative fiction for more than two decades, yet I've only just discovered what made Martin the writer he has become today.

Dreamsongs is a book to own, no question about it. I received ARCs of both volumes, but I'm buying copies of the finished edition for my permanent collection.

Dreamsongs is as engrossing and satisfying as any novel you are likely to read this year. If it's not there already, add this one to your Christmas present list.

The final verdict: 8/10

For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe