New R. Scott Bakker Q&A

I know, I know. . .

I've been promising this one forever and it was a long time in coming. Shit happens, don't you know, and life got in the way, so Bakker couldn't get back to me for quite a while. Well, better late than never, as they say!:-)

Thanks to all the fans who submitted questions for this interview. As you're about to find out, many details have changed since the questions were forwarded to the author last spring. . .

Hope it was worth the wait!
------------------------

- I know you have a visceral fear of spoilers, but you didn't think we'd let you go easy and not ask anything about THE GREAT ORDEAL. We've all read the blurb, of course, but what can you tell us about your upcoming novel?

Where did you get that title? That was just something I cooked up because you need to name the books for the contract. I didn’t like it then, and I don’t like it now. The first book is called, The Judging Eye, that is, unless one of my editors succeeds in arguing me into a different one!

All I’m willing to say is that the story picks up twenty years after the end of The Thousandfold Thought.

- When we spoke at the end of 2005, you were really excited about the prospect of beginning working on The Aspect-Emperor? Has it been a smooth/challenging process thus far?

Writing a book is always challenging, particularly when you’re writing a story across multiple installments, and even more so when you seem constitutively incapable of writing in a straight line like I am. I end up bouncing all over the place rather than sticking to the book at hand. For instance, the last chapter I finished was chapter three - chapter three! WTF...

Also, the fact that this is my career now has really settled in. I had to get my motivational ducks in order for this book - start looking at it as a job, while at the same time preserving my artistic commitments. Easier said than done, at least for me.

- Will we see more of the world -- geographically speaking -- in this new series?

Oh ya...

- In our last interview, you said that you were giddy at the thought of putting the Consult, the Inchoroi, the Nonmen and the Sranc into the narrative spotlight. Do you think fans will be pleased with the results?

I hope so! But it’s literally impossible to tell from the inside of a story what people will think from the outside.

- Are there specific themes you wanted to explore in this second series?

Specifically, I’m interested in what it means to live in a world where value is objective - which is to say, to live in the kind of world our ancestors thought they lived in. Could you imagine, for instance, what it would mean to live in a world where, say, the social and spiritual inferiority of women was a fact like the atomic weight of uranium. Biblical Israel was such as world, as were many others.

We have a hardwired predisposition to "naturalize" our values, to think what we value things is the way things are - it’s one of many liabilities we can chalk up to our stone-age brains. This is why fantasy worlds are our doubles, our psychology writ in geographical stone, and so worth exploring in their own right.

Other than that, there’s a number of carry-over themes dealing with belief and faith as the levers of action.

- Were there any perceived conventions of the fantasy genre which you wanted to twist or break when you set out to write The Prince of Nothing? How about The Aspect-Emperor?

I’m more keen on embracing the conventions than breaking them - the twisting seems to happen of its own accord. The biggie, the one that spans The Second Apocalypse in its entirety, is eschatology - no surprise there. What does it mean to live in a world with an objective narrative structure (which is to say, a world with a climax and an end)? And conversely, what does it mean to live in a world that doesn’t? The others, I think, are pretty obvious.

As for The Aspect-Emperor, my particular interest is the quest, and the ways in which the world itself becomes the primary antagonist. I’m also keen on exploring the idea and role of alternate races, be they sub or super human, as well as - brace yourself! - the young dispossessed king.

- Have the plotlines diverged much since you began writing The Prince of Nothing, or did you have the entire plot more or less figured out from the very beginning? Were any characters added or further fleshed out beyond your original intention? Have you made any changes to your initial plans during the course of the writing of the series?

I know when I started working on The Judging Eye, I found myself inventing a whole series of new viewpoint characters. I didn’t realize what I was doing until I started reading A Feast for Crows, at which point I scrubbed them all save one. I told myself I was adding these new viewpoint characters for the reader’s sake, when in actual fact I was doing it for my own - I mean, multiply the time you’ve spent with The Prince of Nothing by a thousand, and you’ll have a rough ballpark sense of how much time I’ve spent with my cast. The urge to "freshen things up" is almost irresistible, as is the attendant assumption that you’re doing it as much for your readers as for yourself. But when you already have a complicated narrative on the go, you really do risk drifting across that fateful line where your story starts to decohere. Whether or not this was what happened with Martin’s last book, I’m not sure - all I know is that it threw what I was doing into perspective, and led me to take an entirely different tack. It took me a while, but I eventually fell back in love with the old fogies.

And I’ve never stopped being ga-ga over the world. I’m downright conceited when it comes to Earwa. My world kicks some major ass, man.

As a result I really feel as though I’ve been able to strike a better balance between the complexity of the story and the richness of the world in The Judging Eye, as compared to any of The Prince of Nothing books. It’ll be interesting to see what people think.

- Any word on a mass market paperback edition of The Prince of Nothing in the USA?

This summer, or so I’m told.

- How will The Aspect-Emperor differ from the Prince of Nothing trilogy?

Well, I can’t say it’ll be a duology anymore, because in the course of writing it ended taking a parallel form: the story breaks into three natural parts. The first book, The Judging Eye, does the same kind of frame-setting work that The Darkness That Comes Before does in The Prince of Nothing - only without the super-steep learning curve! The second, The Shortest Path, will be a travelogue, much like The Warrior-Prophet, and the third... well let’s just say we’ll be a long time cleaning the fan! One difference, I think, is that the relative lengths of the books will be inverted. The Judging Eye will be the shortest, and I anticipate the final book will be far longer than The Thousandfold Thought, which picked up on the doorstep of Shimeh. This could complicate things, since I would like to include an updated Encyclopaedic Glossary. Maybe I’ll have to break down and do a separate omnibus - but that just feels like a cash grab. Cheesy.

There will be some minor differences in style - I’ve tried to gear the lyricism of my prose more to character than to plot. There will also be substantially less narrative navel gazing - I think that was one area where I erred too much on the literary side in The Prince of Nothing. I want this story to crackle!

- Who will be publishing the Canadian edition? Penguin Canada are saying that they do not have the rights to the Canadian edition of this new book.

Well, someone should tell my editor at Penguin about that!

- Again, without giving anything away, what can you tell us about NEUROPATH? The last time we spoke, you told me that things were brewing in both New York and Hollywood.

Unfortunately, brewing doesn’t always mean beer.

It’s followed almost the same path as The Darkness That Comes Before: I’m swapping genres with this, so I should have expected I would have to prove my point all over again - let’s hope Neuropath pulls through the way The Darkness That Comes Before did! As of just a few weeks ago, I signed with Tor’s Forge Imprint for the US rights, and it looks like it will hit American shelves this upcoming September, several months behind the Canadian and UK releases.

Meanwhile, it’s in development in Hollywood, but so few books get made into movies that it’s like bragging about buying a lottery ticket.

- Characters often take a life of their own. Which of your characters did you find the most unpredictable to write about?

It would have to be the Serwe/Cnaiur dyad. Something so creepy happened that it almost became poetic, to my mind at least. I still feel surprised whenever I think about it.

- What inspired your decision to completely stop posting on the Internet a year ago? Fans say that three-seas.com has been a sad, quiet place since you went to ground.

Owich. Well, according to Jack Brown, one of the fine fellows who run the board, it’s literally receiving millions of hits per year, so maybe I’m a ‘lurker-magnet’ or something...

As for withdrawing from the web, it was just too much mental clutter, on the one hand, and too much of a distraction from work on the other. Imagine working in a room next to another room filled with people who are both slagging and praising you every day. You would have to get sound-proofing, otherwise the impulse to press your ear against the wall would be overwhelming. So now I work on a laptop with no Internet, and try to avoid using this ol’ beast as much as I can.

I steer clear of cell-phones as well. It makes me feel like a secret agent, being all, like, incognito...

- How hard was/is it to get inside Esmenet's head and portray her? What were/are the main inspirations for her character?

I’m afraid Esmenet is one of those characters whose origins extend so far back I can no longer remember them. She was actually one of the easier characters to write - though now, after having learned more about prostitution, I’m inclined to think I romanticized her way too much. The crazy thing is that if I had made her realistic, I’m pretty sure she would have been almost universally despised, and I would have been even more severely criticized for making her "weak."

- How hard is it to write Kellhus? Given his nature and intellect, I presume it must be challenging to make him "believable."

The strange thing is that to write is to be Kellhus - in an sense. In the same way Kellhus can think a dozen thoughts and assess numerous possibilities where others can only think one, I get to spend hours, even days, cooking up stuff for a Kellhus section that only takes several minutes to read. I just keep thinking and thinking and sooner or later I get lucky and come up with something smart or bad-ass sounding to give to Kellhus. He’s the 1% smart-me 100% of the time - which is why I don’t trust him for a second.

- The genre exhibits a strong (albeit recent) tradition for subverting gender stereotypes by presenting worlds in which strong, independent female characters are plausible or even expected. Yet your world is as patriarchal as the reality that inspired it. I expect that this theme makes up for a good part of the discussions you have about your creation, possibly detracting from what you actually want to talk about. Is it difficult to resist the temptation to put something like a bad-ass tomboy warrior-princess with snappy dialogue and a heart of gold into the books?

First, let me say that I think I should be called out on the carpet on this issue, simply because I cover some pretty troubling ground. I certainly don’t believe in "quota characterization," either to be politically correct or to broaden the "gender appeal" of my books. Leave this for the after-school specials. I also don’t think that depiction automatically equals endorsement. The question that people should be asking, it seems to me, is one of whether I reinforce negative gender stereotypes or problematize them. If the books provide enough grist to argue this question, then the answer, it seems to me, automatically becomes the latter.

But the fact remains that a lot of people get hung up on my female characters: On the one hand, I self-consciously chose the harlot, the waif, and the harridan for my female characters, yet some seem to think a kind of unconscious moral defect chose them for me. If so, it would be a truly colossal coincidence that I would happen to pick the three misogynic types - I mean, isn’t it obvious that I’m up to something critical? On the other hand, I wanted my fantasy world to be realistic, to temper our yearning for premodern times with a good look at how ugly things got, particularly in times of war. When bad things happen to my female characters, it’s the circumstances that are being criticized, not the characters themselves!

But people get hunches while they read, and once they do, confirmation bias goes to work (and this is simply one among many reasons why we always buy our own bullshit), and the text, I think, possesses more than enough ambiguities for people spin any number of self-validating interpretations. It’s when they insist their interpretation is the only interpretation, or even worse, that it captures what’s really going on in my bean, that I become baffled.

- M. John Harrison recently wrote this post on his blog:

"Every moment of a science fiction story must represent the triumph of writing over worldbuilding.

Worldbuilding is dull. Worldbuilding literalises the urge to invent. Worldbuilding gives an unneccessary permission for acts of writing (indeed, for acts of reading). Worldbuilding numbs the reader’’s ability to fulfil their part of the bargain, because it believes that it has to do everything around here if anything is going to get done.

Above all, worldbuilding is not technically neccessary. It is the great clomping foot of nerdism. It is the attempt to exhaustively survey a place that isn’’t there. A good writer would never try to do that, even with a place that is there. It isn’’t possible, & if it was the results wouldn’’t be readable: they would constitute not a book but the biggest library ever built, a hallowed place of dedication & lifelong study. This gives us a clue to the psychological type of the worldbuilder & the worldbuilder’’s victim, & makes us very afraid."

Needless to say, a multitude of people disagree with Harrison's postulation. What's your take on Harrison's post and the concept of worldbuilding in general?

As a diehard grognardian world-junkie myself, I obviously disagree. But it is a blog, which means that it’s probably written without much forethought. Consider his observation that worldbuilding can never "exhaustively survey a place that isn’t there." Who thinks that the "biggest library ever built" is a goal any writer seriously entertains? You can't do it, the argument seems to be, so why bother trying? But no one outside of characters in Borges stories have ever tried to do this. No one. Ever. He’s just riffing without thinking here.

And he’s also referring to science fiction, where the situation is somewhat different than in fantasy. It makes me wonder what he would think of a work like Neil Stephenson’s Diamond Age, where much of the worldbuilding isn’t "technically necessary," and yet necessary all the same. My guess is that it probably boils down to worldbuilding he enjoys reading versus worldbuilding he doesn’t, and his arguments are just ad hoc rationalizations.

The "clomping foot of nerdism" sounds pretty cool. Makes me feel like a bespectacled, buck-toothed Godzilla, building worlds instead of tearing them down. Aaaargh!

What troubles me most though are the unconditional, declarative tone - as though it’s the most obvious thing in the world that worldbuilders are "bad writers" - and the insinuations regarding the psychological type of the worldbuilder.

Worldbuilding either is or is not "necessary" depending on the effects the writer is hoping to achieve. Of course Harrison would say that worldbuilders, such as myself, are trying to achieve the wrong effects. Detailing a world beyond the technical requirements of the story, the implication is, simply turns readers into literary shopkeepers with inventories to keep and no meaningful choices to make. Thus the frightening psychology: apparently the worldbuilder’s goal is to cretinize their readers, keep’em dumb and distracted so that they can be better exploited by the powers that be.

For Harrison, who is an avowed post-modernist, the reader should be continually confronted with the performative as opposed to the representational function of language. They should be reminded (apparently over and over and over) of the power of words to spin realities, to the point where the work becomes a multifarious, promiscuous, meaning event (albeit one that is too often generated by the most mechanical of po-mo tactics, elision). Forcing the reader to draw whole characters out of fragments, narrative arcs out of discordant events - to "fulfill their part of the bargain" - this is the true way to make the reader an active part of the process, and so a critically minded, enlightened citizen.

I don’t know whether to laugh or yawn anymore. For better or worse, readers without literature degrees tend to hate this stuff. They like coherent characters and stories and settings. So when you start screwing with "representational expectations" (in other words, unilaterally rewriting the "bargain") by and large all you end up doing is preaching to the choir, writing for people with literature degrees, which is to say, for people who already share your values. In other words, you simply end up catering to their expectations. You become an "upscale" version of the very commercial entertainers you continually denigrate.

We’re hardwired for this shit, which is why you see the same pattern repeating itself over and over in every sphere of cultural production. Every sphere has a self-styled elite who both identify and flatter themselves via their values, then criticize others for not sharing those values. "Our values are the values and you guys are losers because of this and this and this..."

This pattern bums me out because it swallows so much talent in our society and aims it inward. Harrison really is a prodigious talent, but he can’t seem to see his way past this post-modern crap. This is another universal human pattern: whatever your yardstick happens to be, nothing else seems to measure up - it quickly becomes the yardstick.

Don’t blame the cretinized masses for not reading your stuff. If you really are afraid, if you really are a writer with a social conscience, then go out and meet them. Write something that communicates to them, and not just to those who already share your values. Stop writing for "yourself," or for the "page," or for whatever clever euphemism you use to cover the fact that you’re simply a producer of a kind of a high-end cultural commodity.

Until you do, you’re just another entertainer. Which is okay, so long as you’re not pretending otherwise. Say, "I write for people like me, and I’m not all that interested in making a social difference."

Me, I don’t know what my yardstick is half the time. All I know is that I think its important to write stories that challenge readers, and that if I write "literary stuff" my audience will self-select and I’ll just end up catering to expectations and so not really challenging anybody. What’s the use of pissing in the soup if its made of urine anyway?

When it comes to worldbuilding, I'm simply trying to tell a story that happens in a fantasy world bigger than that story. And there’s meaning-effects aplenty to be explored here, believe you me. Profound ones.

In fact, the very thing worldbuilders are probing is the selfsame power of words to spin realities, a power which is intensified when the writer approaches the world and the story as separate works - when the writer is also a worldbuilder. I personally think this is one of the keys to Tolkien's elusive magic: imagine The Lord of the Rings without a separately crafted Middle-earth! And because it resonates with a broad cross-section of readers, I think epic worldbuilding provides a powerful opportunity to communicate, one which "literary minded" writers are less likely to explore because of incredibly narrow "literary virtues" like those espoused here and elsewhere by Harrison.

But I imagine Harrison would think this power to spin realities, which is the one we regularly confront on the evening news, holds no "real" literary interest for "good" writers. I'm guessing it focuses too much on the pernicious representational aspects of language, and so numbs readers into forgetting all the ways language dupes and deceives - which is why they vote Bush (and why we should be afraid, I'm supposing).

But what if it works the other way? What if the canned experimentalism of post-modernism, by leaving so many readers behind, reinforces the general anti-intellectualism that seems to characterize our culture, and so makes anti-intellectual politicians like Bush more appealing? This only needs to be an open question to throw a rather severe light on the political undertones of Harrison's position. He could be the very scourge he's disparaging.

- Anything else you wish to share with your fans?

One thing: read A Mind of its Own by Cordelia Fine. You are not who you think you are - this is simply a fact. The quicker we as a species come to grips with this, the greater our chances of surviving the technologically mediated madness just over the horizon. Read it, then pass it on.

Is There Nepotism in Science Fiction

Once again, I have Larry to thank for finding this interesting article by Carol Pinchefsky.

Here's an excerpt:

Editors mingle with each other, as well as professional and fledgling writers, publishers, agents at science fiction conventions and other events. Many of them have longstanding personal as well as business relationships, including traveling together, sharing hotel rooms, and dating, marrying, and sometimes divorcing one another.

Add fans into the mix, some of whom have been attending conventions and meeting their favorite writers and editors for decades, and well, the word "incestuous" springs to mind.

Because of this ultra-socialization in the genre, editors tend to buy stories and novels from people that they often already know, at least tangentially.

Does knowing an editor personally -- and buying him a round at the bar -- increase a writer's chances of getting published? Are editors swayed by the charms of friendship and the chance to write off every lunch as a business expense? Is there favoritism in science fiction?

Read the whole article here.

The Solaris Book of New Fantasy contest winner!

Sorry about the delay! The winner's name was drawn during the Holidays, but I only now realized that I had never made the announcement! My bad. . .

Thanks to the nice folks at Solaris, our lucky winner will get his hands on The Solaris Book of New Fantasy (Canada, USA, Europe), which contains short stories by authors such as Lucius Shepard, Hal Duncan and Steven Erikson.

The winner is:

Paul Smith, from Hamilton, Ontario, Canada

Thanks to all the participants!:-)

American Gods

Given the hype surrounding this title, it was only natural to have such high hopes for what became Neil Gaiman's signature work. American Gods was an intelligent and gripping read from the very first page, and it should live up to most readers' lofty expectations. It certainly did for me, in any case!

As is the author's wont, Gaiman takes us on an enjoyable and unforgettable ride. He is a master storyteller, no doubt. His brand of witty humor can be found throughout this yarn, yet make no mistake: American Gods is a thoughtful tale that resounds with depth. The way he tinkers with the various mythologies forming the backdrop of this novel is nothing short of astounding.

At times hilarious and at times poignant, American Gods is a well-balanced book. Rich in emotions and details, with well-crafted characters and storylines, as well as an arresting imagery, this one will keep you reading well past your bedtime a few days running. I was utterly captivated, and I didn't want it to end.

It's not just Gaiman's fertile imagination which imbues this novel with so much life. No, it's the author's uncanny perception of the world around him which makes American Gods such a genuine study of the cultural heritage of the multiethnic population that is endemic to the USA.

Neil Gaiman has captured the American "small town" feel like few writers have been able to do, especially considering that he is not American himself. It feels as though he managed to condense the very essence of what is the United States of America, in all its complexity and idiosyncraties.

In the end, American Gods is many things: Provocative, moving, engrossing, funny, original. But most of all, it's a wonderful read accessible to any reader looking for a quality read. It's no surprise, then, to realize that this title was able to transcend the boundaries of speculative fiction.

Once more, I have to wonder how I could let this book sit there for so long. If, like me, you already own this fantastic novel, please put it at the very top of your "books to read" pile. And if you don't already have a copy, I suggest you buy it ASAP. Doubtless, American Gods will be one of your favorite reads of the year!

The final verdict: 9/10

For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe

NFL Showdown: GRRM vs Pat



Just received this little nugget of entertainement, courtesy of one George R. R. Martin...

Never thought I'd see the day when I would agree with basically everything Hitler is saying!!!:p

This week's New York Times Bestsellers (January 15th)

In hardcover:

Drew Karpyshyn's Darth Bane: Rule of Two is up two positions, ending its second week on the charts at number 12. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Terry Goodkind's Confessor maintains its position at number 17. This marks the novel's ninth week on the NYT list. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Anne and Todd McCaffrey's Dragon Harper is down four spots, finishing its second week on the bestseller list at number 27. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

In paperback:

Patricia Briggs' Iron Kissed debuts at number 1. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Richard Matheson's I am Legend is down one spot, finishing its eleventh week on the charts at number 3. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Cormac McCarthy's The Road is up two positions, ending its 40th week on the prestigious list at number 7. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Timothy Zahn's Star Wars: Allegiance is up three spots, finishing its second week on the NYT list at number 22. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Tad Williams' new website

Thanks to Olaf for the "heads up!":-)

Bestselling SFF author Tad Williams has a new website. I just took a look around and it's pretty cool. There's a ton of info and a message boards. And there's Tad's blog as well, so check it out!

You can find it here: http://www.tadwilliams.com/

Kudos to the designers!;-)

Patrick Rothfuss speaks out on the delay of THE WISE MAN'S FEAR

Since I was the person who broke the news to the Blogosphere last fall, it's only natural that I post a link to Rothfuss' explanation.

If anyone remains pissed off about the unfortunate delay after reading this, then it's your own damn problem. . . The Wise Man's Fear will be released when it's ready.

Read Rothfuss' blog post here.

Cover art for Richard Morgan's THE STEEL REMAINS

Don't know if this is breaking news, but I haven't seen it anywhere else.

I really like this cover art.:-)

For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Steven Erikson's TOLL THE HOUNDS cover art

Just saw this on http://www.malazanworld.com/.

Not exactly what I expected, but not bad either. . .

Coming Attractions

Here's what I have on tap for the next couple of weeks. . .

Book Reviews

I've decided to do something about the ever-growing backlog of books I have to read. Reviewing new and upcoming releases is all well and good, but I have a number of terrific novels awaiting my attention. Some of them have been sitting there for years, and it's high time for me to give them a shot. I've just read GRRM's A Storm of Swords and I'm now enjoying Neil Gaiman's American Gods (Canada, USA, Europe).

Coming up next should be Carrie Vaughn's Kitty and the Silver Bullet (Canada, USA, Europe) and Jack Whyte's Standard of Honor (Canada, USA, Europe). I haven't made up my mind as to what will follow, but don't be surprised if it's Steven Erikson's Blood Follows (Canada, USA, Europe) and The Healthy Dead (Canada, USA, Europe). Neal Stephenson's Cryptonomicon is another title which has been gathering dust on my shelves for years, so I should read it in the near future. Of course, Joe Abercrombie's Last Argument of Kings will move to the top of the "books to read" pile as soon as my ARC appears in my mailbox.

Don't be surprised if you see me post reviews of novels by Sergei Lukyanenko and Peter F. Hamilton in the coming weeks. I go by feel, so I never really know what I'll read next. Still, I have a panoply of great books waiting to be read, so I mean to read and review a few of them this winter. . .

Also, it will be interesting to see what George R. R. Martin will make me read for losing our NFL wager.

Interviews

I'm waiting to hear back from both Jack Whyte and James Barclay. It's been months, but R. Scott Bakker promised me that the interview we did last spring will one day see the light!

I've contacted Del Rey about the possibility to do a Q&A with Terry Brooks. It would be to promote his forthcoming graphic novel, so we'll have to wait and see. . .

Other than that, nothing is set in stone as of right now.

Giveaways

I have a number of terrific contests on the way, so stay tuned for that!;-)

February will be Joe Abercrombie's month, with no less than 2 different giveaways! I will have a couple of copies of the US edition of Before They Are Hanged to pass along, as well as three autographed copies of the UK edition of Last Argument of Kings.

In addition, and that's quite a treat, I will have one ARC of the Subterranean Press limited edition of Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash (Canada, USA, Europe). Prizes don't get much rarer than that! Speaking of Subpress, keep an eye out for giveaways for the limited editions of Steven Erikson's Gardens of the Moon and Richard Morgan's Altered Carbon.

There will also be a giveaway for a set of Mike Carey's Felix Castor books. I really enjoyed The Devil you Know (Canada, USA, Europe), so hopefully more and more people can discover this talented writer and his work.

I have a few more contests cooking up, but nothing that can be confirmed just yet. So visit the blog to make sure you don't miss out on anything!

Stay tuned for more!:-)

A Storm of Swords

What !?! You haven't read George R. R. Martin's A Storm of Swords!?! I figure that many newbies will be shocked to learn that such is the case. The funny thing is that I bought the novel when it was originally published in hardcover. Yeah, way back in 2000. . . If you wish to discover how I was able to show such self-control, read my reviews of both A Game of Thrones and A Clash of Kings. And if you must blame someone for my shortcoming, then blame GRRM. I certainly do!;-)

The hype surrounding A Storm of Swords has reached such a degree that I felt it was well nigh impossible for the book to live up to such high expectations. Hence, though I was aware that the novel would be good, I expected to feel a certain sense of disappointement as well. Oddly enough, regardless of the unbelievably lofty expectations, A Storm of Swords more than lives up to the hype. Astonishingly so, to be honest. The third volume of A Song of Ice and Fire elevates the series to a level which is seldom attained. It is indeed one of the best fantasy novels I have ever read.

What is probably the most remarkable feature of this book is that, although it weighs in at 973 pages in hardback, there is not a single dull moment throughout. Martin plotted and paced this one close to perfection. Unlike Jordan, who bored and aggravated us countless times with sequences showcasing the endless bickering of Elayne, Aviendha and Nynaeve, or Erikson with those Mhybe chapters, in A Storm of Swords GRRM keeps his writing tight and the rhythm crisp. In and of itself, considering the length of the book, that's incredible. Time flies by, and it feels as though you're reading a 300-page thriller.

Another facet which differentiates Martin from his peers is the structure of the series. GRRM's multiple-character POV format precludes him from producing something as vast in scope as The Wheel of Time or The Malazan Book of the Fallen, even though ASOIAF is a far-reaching saga. And yet, it gives the reader a more intimate look at what is occurring, allowing us a delve more profoundly into each character and thus experiencing their motivations with more depth, which in turn gives us the opportunity to a undergo a more "genuine" reading experience. At times it feels as though you're right there. And in the end, that's something that no other fantasy author can provide -- at least not at this level.

Needless to say, there are more twists and turns in A Storm of Swords than in most fantasy series. This volume moves the story forward much more than the previous two put together. It will be interesting to see how the repercussions will reverberate in the subsequent ASOIAF installments.

Though the plotting and politicking remain two of my favorite aspects of the series, the characterization is the facet which makes A Song of Ice and Fire what it is. My favorite characters -- Jon, Tyrion and Arya -- somehow managed to survive yet another book. No small feat, considering the body count in this one! I was surprised by how easily GRRM was able to make us root for characters that used to be the "bad guys," such as Jaime and the Hound.

I felt that the epilogue was particularly anti-climactic, until I discovered who the cloaked figure turned out to be. What a way to leave the readers hanging. . .

The American Tolkien -- or so has George R. R. Martin been dubbed. I think not. . . No disrespect, but J. R. R. Tolkien never wrote anything this good.

The final verdict: 10/10
For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe

Amazon.co.uk is doing it again!

Last summer, Amazon.co.uk had heaps of SFF titles on sale for up to 50% off! Needless to say, a whole lot of readers to advantage of that sale.

Well, it does seem that they're doing it again. Browsing around, I saw that Joe Abercrombie's Last Argument of Kings can be pre-ordered at a 50% discount (45% for the hardcover). Titles by authors such as Scott Lynch, Patrick Rothfuss, Steven Erikson, and more can be purchased at 30% to 50% off.
Once again, I wonder why its US and Canadian counterparts can't do the same???:-(

Check it out here.

Download Robin Hobb's SHAMAN'S CROSSING for free!

To celebrate their 10th anniversary, throughout 2008 Eos will be giving away free e-books. To kick things off, the inaugural title you can download free of charge is the first volume of Robin Hobb's The Soldier Son trilogy, Shaman's Crossing. Keep an eye on Eos' blog for future free e-books!;-)

You can download Shaman's Crossing by clicking on this link.

So close. . .

Fucking Dallas Cowboys. . .:-(

When Romo threw that last second interception, my dream of getting brutally murdered in A Dance with Dragons evaporated. Losing isn't that bad. But losing to the hated Giants, that's something else. Cowboys fans saw it coming, of course. Losing steam at the end of the season wasn't a good sign. Meanwhile, New York finished stronger and looked pretty damn good against Tampa Bay last week. Only to lose in the blizzard of Green Bay next week, but what the heck?

Man, I so wanted to die in the next ASOIAF volume!;-) That pisses me off a LOT more than the football game. It will be interesting to see what George will make me read. . .

So damn close. . .

Win a copy of George R. R. Martin, Gardner Dozois and Daniel Abraham's HUNTER'S RUN

After giving you guys a chance to win the UK edition and the Subterrenean Press limited edition, thanks to the good folks at Eos I now have five copies of the US edition of GRRM, Dozois and Abraham's Hunter's Run up for grabs! For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

The rules are the same as usual. First off, you need to send an email at reviews@(no-spam)gryphonwood.net with the header "RUN." Remember to remove the "no spam" thingy.

Second, your email must contain your full mailing address (that's snail mail!), otherwise your message will be deleted.

Lastly, multiple entries will disqualify whoever sends them. And please include your screen name and the message boards that you frequent using it, if you do hang out on a particular MB.

Good luck to all the participants!

Win a copy of Robin Hobb's RENAGADE'S MAGIC

I know I ran a contest for the UK version of this novel last fall, but here's your chance to win a copy of the US edition of Robin Hobb's Renegade's Magic, courtesy of Eos. I have five copies up for grabs! For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

The rules are the same as usual. First off, you need to send an email at reviews@(no-spam)gryphonwood.net with the header "NEVARE." Remember to remove the "no spam" thingy.

Second, your email must contain your full mailing address (that's snail mail!), otherwise your message will be deleted.

Lastly, multiple entries will disqualify whoever sends them. And please include your screen name and the message boards that you frequent using it, if you do hang out on a particular MB.

Good luck to all the participants!

Transworld have big plans for Steven Erikson in 2008

Erikson's publicist just forwarded me a press release which indicates that 2008 will be a busy year for Steven Erikson and The Malazan Book of the Fallen. Here's what they have on tap:

February will bring the reissue of the series' opening chapter, Gardens of the Moon, with the new cover art and an exclusive introduction, all for a bargain price to entice new readers to pick it up.

April will bring the paperback edition of Reaper's Gale, and will include a teaser from Toll the Hounds.

June will see the release of the eagerly anticipated Toll the Hounds. For the very first time, this latest Malazan volume will get a hardback release. Indeed, the trade paperback of Toll the Hounds won't hit the stores until the fall.

Even better, Steven Erikson will visit the UK around the publication of Toll the Hounds, and will thus attend bookshop signings, readings, and related events.

As if this wasn't enough, the icing on the cake will be the publication of Ian Cameron Esslemont's Return of the Crimson Guard, first as a limited edition from PS Publishing this spring, and then with the "official" release coming later in the summer.

All in all, quite a good year from Malazan fans!:-)

This week's New York Times Bestsellers (January 8th)

In hardcover:

Drew Karpyshyn's Star Wars: Darth Bane: Rule of Two debuts at number 14. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Terry Goodkind's Confessor maintains its position at number 17. This marks the novel's eighth week on the charts. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Anne and Todd McCaffrey's Dragon Harper debuts at number 23. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

J. R. R. Tolkien's The Children of Húrin is down seven spots, ending the week at number 30. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

R. A. Salvatore's The Orc King is down one position, finishing the week at number 32. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

In paperback:

Richard Matheson's I am Legend maintains its position at number 2. This marks the book's tenth week on the NYT list. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Cormac McCarthy's The Road is down two spots, finishing its 39th week on the bestseller list at number 9. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Dan Simmons' The Terror debuts at number 29. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Win a copy of the reissue of Steven Erikson's GARDENS OF THE MOON

Thanks to the kind folks at Bantam Press, I have five copies of the reissue of Erikson's fantasy debut, Gardens of the Moon, for you guys to win. So if you've always wanted to see what the Malazan buzz was all about, here's your chance! This edition sports the new cover art and contains a new foreword by the author. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

The rules are the same as usual. First off, you need to send an email at reviews@(no-spam)gryphonwood.net with the header "SORRY." Remember to remove the "no spam" thingy.

Second, your email must contain your full mailing address (that's snail mail!), otherwise your message will be deleted.

Lastly, multiple entries will disqualify whoever sends them. And please include your screen name and the message boards that you frequent using it, if you do hang out on a particular MB.

Good luck to all the participants!

Cover art for the limited edition of Neal Stephenson's SNOW CRASH

Speaking of Subterranean Press, they will soon release a special limited edition of Neal Stephenson's classic, Snow Crash. Collectors will probably brawl among themselves to get a copy of this one!;-)

For more info about Snow Crash: Canada, USA, Europe, or http://www.subterraneanpress.com/.

I'll have to check with Bill to see if we'll do a giveaway for this one. . .

Win a copy of the limited edition of Naomi Novik's HIS MAJESTY'S DRAGON

This is our very first giveaway of 2008, and it's a good one! Thanks to Bill and his crew, one lucky winner will get his or her hands on the Subpress limited edition of Naomi Novik's fantasy debut. This contest has been in the works for a while, but now that it's finally going to the printer the time has come to make the announcement. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe, or http://www.subterraneanpress.com/.

The rules are the same as usual. First off, you need to send an email at reviews@(no-spam)gryphonwood.net with the header "TEMERAIRE." Remember to remove the "no spam" thingy.

Second, your email must contain your full mailing address (that's snail mail!), otherwise your message will be deleted.

Lastly, multiple entries will disqualify whoever sends them. And please include your screen name and the message boards that you frequent using it, if you do hang out on a particular MB.

Good luck to all the participants!:-)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars trailer



If you ask me, this looks pretty damn good!:-)

UK cover art for R. Scott Bakker's NEUROPATH

Thanks to Larry for the "heads up!"

Can't say I like this one. . .

Last Dragon

Discoveries is a new speculative fiction imprint from Wizards of the Coast (Dragonlance, Forgotten Realms, etc). Hence, let me begin by saying that it's about time! A new adult-oriented specfic line is good news to fans of the genre.

Wizards of the Coast sent out a very neat publicity kit last fall. Of all the advance reading copies it contained, I elected to read J. M. McDermott's debut. Last Dragon is advertized as a literary fantasy novel in the tradition of Gene Wolfe and Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Talk about raising expectations to a level that no debut can aspire to reach, right? Still, I was intrigued and decided to give it a shot.

As a matter of course, Last Dragon doesn't live up to such lofty expectations. Which is not to say that it's a bad book, mind you. McDermott's debut has a lot of good things going for it, yet the book also suffers from a number of shortcomings.

Last Dragon is written economically, which is both a positive and a negative thing. On the upside, it makes for a narrative that flows well. Extremely short scenes in relatively short chapters help speed the story along. On the downside, many of the concepts are bare bones and should have been further fleshed out to make this tale more absorbing.

The narrative jumps from one point to another along the past and the future of the novel's timeline. This works rather well at the onset of the tale, but it becomes increasingly confusing as the story moves along.

For those who, like me, like to visualize, the absence of a map makes it hard to picture where the cast is located across the timeline. The characters travel around the world quite a bit, and I could never really tell where they were at any point in time.

McDermott's economical prose also hurts him in terms of worldbuilding. He introduces many facets which appear quite interesting, yet he never truly follows up with much details, which turns several good ideas into missed opportunities. This in turn leads to a number of disappointments, as readers habitually want to learn more. Indeed, what starts off as compelling plot points deteriorate gradually and become somewhat monotonous storylines.

The same could be said regarding the characterization, I'm afraid. McDermott's cast of characters is engaging at the beginning of the novel. Zhan, Seth, Adel, Fest and the others show a lot of promise. Unfortunately, the absence of details to flesh them out more means that there is little character growth. Or, more exactly, the characters evolve during the course of the tale, but the reader doesn't witness the transition. We know close to nothing about their personalities and motives.

I'm well aware that I don't say this very often, but I believe that Last Dragon should have been longer. It would have given the author the chance to bring this book to another level, for the potential is definitely there. The absence of details concerning too many facets of the novel makes for a somewhat bland story that could have been a lot better. It's sad, for Last Dragon showed a lot of promise. . .
It will be interesting to see how Wizards of the Coast will market this new line, as it will not appeal to their usual readers.

The final verdict: 6.75/10

For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe

French cover art for Erikson's DEADHOUSE GATES

To be honest, they should have stayed with the sublime original Deadhouse Gates cover from Bantam Press. . .

NFL Showdown: GRRM vs Pat

Well, you might say that this is where we separate the men from the boys.

By finishing on top of the NFC and securing home field throughout the playoffs, the Dallas Cowboys have the weekend off. Which means that if the New York Giants lose to Tampa Bay tomorrow afternoon, I'm going to be offed by GRRM in A Dance with Dragons.

If the damned G-Men win, however, we have to do it all over again next week. . .

I just want to be killed in the next ASOIAF volume. Is that so selfish of me!?!:p

The Hotlist is a contender!

It just came to my attention that Pat's Fantasy Hotlist is among the nominees for The Preditors & Editors Readers' Poll, which honors print & electronic publications published during 2007. It's kind of cool, considering some of the sites this blog is up against.

To learn more, check out http://www.critters.org/predpoll/reviewsite.shtml. You have until January 15th to vote for the Hotlist or any other review site.

Best of luck to all the contenders!:-)

This week's New York Times Bestsellers (January 1st)

In hardcover:

Terry Goodkind's Confessor is down one position, ending its seventh week on the charts at number 17. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

J. R. R. Tolkien's The Children of Húrin is up one spot, finishing at number 23. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

R. A. Salvatore's The Orc King returns on the bestseller list at number 31. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

In paperback:

Richard Matheson's I am Legend maintains its position at number 2. This marks the book's ninth week on the NYT list. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Cormac McCarthy's The Road is up one spot, finishing its 38th week on the prestigious list at number 7. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Aaron Allston's Star Wars: Legacy of the Force: Fury debuts at number 20. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Orson Scott Card's Empire is down four positions, ending its second week on the bestseller list at number 25. For more info about this title: Canada, USA, Europe.

Wild Cards contest winners!

Okay, so this giveaway turned out to be quite popular, and with good reason! Thanks to the nice folks at Tor Books, our two winners will get their hands on Advance Reading Copies of the latest Wild Cards novel, Inside Straight (Canada, USA, Europe). Moreover, the books are signed by all nine collaborators and will be personalized by George R. R. Martin himself! Is that cool or what!?!;-)

I read and reviewed Inside Straight a few weeks back, and I really enjoyed it. You guys should definitely check it out!

The winners are:

- Josh Stone, from San Jose, California, USA

- Steve Spaulding, from Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA (RaceBannon42 on asoiaf.westeros.org)

Thanks to all the participants!