Terry Pratchett and his Discworld series need no introduction. Indeed, given the fact that the series has sold over 45 million copies worldwide, Pratchett's latest requires very little in the way of hype. By now, when one purchases a Disworld novel, one should know what to expect. And though making people laugh is not an easy gig, the author, somehow, always rises up to the challenge and delivers a book that lives up to the high expectations which are inherent to any Pratchett new release.
4 comments
I read your review of this book, one which I am impatiently anticipating. I know you want to remain "spoiler-free", but the review doesn't read well. It reads like the back of the book and generalizing what most people could guess from the plot summary on the back cover. The most confusing aspect of this is that you gush about it for the entire review, and then give the book a 7.5/10- what? Obviously, there was something off or you would have rated it higher- why did you not point this out in your review? I'm not saying you have to like the book, but if you are going to review it (then advertise it), you should at least point out some good and bad things about it.
Brandi,
I never include spoilers in my reviews. If you take a look around, you'll see that it's the case for everything I do.
Plus, this book is strictly embargoed until September 24th. If I were to include spoilers, I could lose my privilege to receive ARCs in the future...
MAKING MONEY is a good book, but it remains a comedy. I love American Pie, yet it will never have the quality of Schindler's List...
So patience, for you only have a few more days to go.:-)
I guess I meant more of a "why was it rated low" instead of "why aren't their spoilers". I don't mind spoiler-free reviews, but it's hard to gauge what you really thought about it when the review is a recap of the back of the book and nothing more. The only thing I picked up was that the book was "light fantasy", which I'm not actually sure what that means. Is it just what you label comedy? Is it being a comedy what caused you to mark it down? Were some of the jokes not quite there or was the story a bit disappointing? That's all stuff that you can comment on without giving plot away :) You obviously love to read and write, so I just wanted to point out some problems which I found. So maybe in this case, it was a "critique" of your critique :)
Thanks again, and thanks for responding.
Post a Comment
Contributors
SFF Message Boards
Publishers
SFF Resources
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(341)
-
▼
July
(19)
- Joel Shepherd contest winners!
- Win a copy of Joe Abercrombie's BEST SERVED COLD
- Ian McDonald contest winners!
- Quote of the Day
- Win a full set of Mark Chadbourn's THE AGE OF MISR...
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (July 7th)
- Go see this show!
- A GAME OF THRONES TV Series in Time Magazine
- Win a copy of Steven Erikson's DUST OF DREAMS
- The Angel's Game (200th book review)
- Kevin J. Anderson contest winners!
- Worldcon: Montreal Restaurant Guide
- Quote of the Day
- R. Scott Bakker video interview
- New Poll: What scifi novel should I read next?
- This week's New York Times' Bestsellers (June 30th...
- Win a copy of STRANGE BREW edited by P. N. Elrod
- Quote of the Day
- Daniel Abraham contest winners!
-
►
June
(53)
- Wanna help out???
- Look what the cat dragged in. . .
- Ian Cameron Esslemont contest winner!
- Quote of the Day
- Chuck Norris is back!
- Excerpt from Robin Hobb's DRAGON KEEPER
- For the record. . .
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (June 23rd)...
- Fall of Thanes
- Win a copy of Joel Shepherd's KILLSWITCH
- Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
- Dan Abnett contest winners!
- Provisional Top 5 of 2009
- Signed limited edition of Joe Abercrombie's THE BL...
- Another lucrative book deal; this time for Brandon...
- Win a copy of Ian McDonald's DESOLATION ROAD
- Las Vegas pictures
- Slowly but surely. . .
- Let's stop sneering at fantasy readers
- Speculative Horizons: Update
- SFF authors' favorite real-life fantasy/scifi citi...
- Alastair Reynolds signs a million-pound book deal!...
- Win a copy of Kevin J. Anderson's THE EDGE OF THE ...
- The David Gemmell Legend Award
- Quote of the Day
- Win a copy of Daniel Abraham's THE PRICE OF SPRING...
- Preview of WHEEL OF TIME: EYE OF THE WORLD #1
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (June 16th)...
- Brandon Sanderson video interview
- Pathetic. . .
- Cover art for Glen Cook's THE RETURN OF THE BLACK ...
-
▼
July
(19)
Index of Reviews and Interviews
Fantasy Blogs of Interest
- A Dribble of Ink
- Blogorob
- Blood of the Muse
- Fantasy Book Critic
- Fantasy Debut
- Fantasy/Scifi Book Review
- Graeme's Fantasy Book Reviews
- Grasping for the Wind
- Mysterious Outposts
- NextRead
- OF Blog of the Fallen
- Pyr-o-Mania
- Realms of Speculative Fiction
- Sandstorm Reviews
- Scifi Chick
- Speculative Fiction Junkie
- Speculative Horizons
- Speculative Reviews
- SQT Fantasy-Scifi Girl
- The Bodhisattva
- The Book Swede
- The Genre Files
- The Gravel Pit
- The Neth Space
- The Soulless Machine Review
- The Swivet
- The Wertzone
Speculative Fiction Authors
- Joe Abercrombie
- Daniel Abraham
- R. Scott Bakker
- Tobias S. Buckell
- Jacqueline Carey
- Stephen R. Donaldson
- Hal Duncan
- David Anthony Durham
- David Louis Edelman
- S. L. Farrell
- Raymond E. Feist
- C. S. Friedman
- Neil Gaiman
- Peter F. Hamilton
- Robin Hobb
- J. V. Jones
- Guy Gavriel Kay
- Paul Kearney
- Kay Kenyon
- Stephen King
- Katherine Kurtz
- Sergey Lukyanenko
- Scott Lynch
- George R. R. Martin
- GRRM's Not a Blog
- Ian McDonald
- L. E. Modesitt, jr.
- Richard Morgan
- Naomi Novik
- Terry Pratchett
- Melanie Rawn
- Alastair Reynolds
- Patrick Rothfuss
- Brian Ruckley
- Brandon Sanderson
- Ekaterina Sedia
- Joel Shepherd
- Dan Simmons
- Melinda Snodgrass
- Jeff Somers
- Neal Stephenson
- Carrie Vaughn
- Peter Watts
- Tad Williams
- Jack Whyte





