
Other than Neil Gaiman's The Sandman, it's been about two decades since I've read comic books on a regular basis. Hence, I have given no thought regarding the much-publicized DC Relaunch.
And yet, I feel that Tim Callahan wrote an interesting article titled "The DC Relaunch Week Three: The Sexuality of Superheroes" for Tor.com. Here's an extract:
This week, DC launched twelve new series, and I’m practically at a loss for words. Not because this week, overall, was considerably better or worse than the previous two weeks, but because the comics this week show a troubling schizophrenia on the part of the DC editorial team. This is the week that saw Wonder Woman #1 and Catwoman #1 debut. New series featuring the two most prominent DC female characters. One of them is magnificent, the other is abominable.
[...]
The reason this week is so difficult to write about isn’t because Wonder Woman is such a good first issue (though it is). It’s because Catwoman is so bad and the way it’s bad is so frustratingly illustrative of one of the major problems of the direct market comic book industry that the conversation will inevitably veer off into the direction of sexual politics and objectification and sexism and pandering. And while that conversation is necessary, and I’ll get to it soon enough, it pushes aside most other DC comics of the week, and makes them seem insignificant by comparison because they don’t play a part in the dialogue about sexuality in mainstream comics. Or, maybe even worse, it forces that lens onto the rest of the comics, even if they are mostly innocently going about their business of alien exoskeleton technology or lamentations about the good old days at the circus.
[...]
Yet, I can’t help but read it as a commentary on the implicit sexuality of the character dating back to the Marv Wolfman/George Perez days. In those comics from 25+ years ago, Starfire was a flying, glowing Barbarella with a naïve demeanor. There was no doubt that she was presented, within the story and to the reader, as a sex object, even if it was done in a more innocent manner than we see here. It’s difficult to raise objections to the characterization of Starfire when this is just an exaggerated, more explicit version of who she was before. It’s an interpretation that identifies the elephant in the room and labels it “elephant, in room, pay attention, it’s sexy and dumb.”
It still makes for a sleazy, insipid comic though.
Not as sleazy or insipid as Catwoman #1, a comic which I quite erroneously predicted would be “clean family fun” when I previewed the series this summer based on initial speculation and Judd Winick’s own statements. The cover certainly hints at what’s inside — that’s no metaphorical image on that issue #1 cover, just a skanky-looking Catwoman dripping jewels on her breasts. Keep this in mind: I’ve read plenty of Judd Winick comics, and I have mostly disliked them all, but this first issue might be the most off-putting thing he’s ever written. Like Red Hood, it takes the implicit and makes it explicit, but such a move does not make for a comic that you’d actually want to read.
[...]
So what exactly is my problem with this comic that begins with a four page sequence depicting Catwoman running from bad guys while trying to get dressed and ends with her undressing Batman with the internal monologue stating, “…it doesn’t take long…and most of the costumes stay on”? Is it that the comic dares to show the sexuality behind the superhero façade? Or the comic panders to the direct market audience so overtly — an audience that has sustained the careers of Billy Tucci and Jim Balent and countless others of the sort? Or that it’s just a poorly executed comic?
Can I choose all three? Is that allowed?
Because, yes, it does show the sexuality behind the superhero façade, but that doesn’t mean it’s a good idea. The Catwoman character is predicated on the sexual tension between her and Batman, and while it may be daring to completely invalidate that by actually consummating their relationship in the opening issue, it also turns the character into nothing but a fetishized object. She is not even a character in this first issue, just an embodiment of sexuality and violence.
Follow this link to read the full article.
The funny thing about this is that there were similar discussions on this very topic back in the early 90s when I was buying all those Image titles. It's nice to see how things have evolved over the years. . .
For better or worse, sex continues to sell. And there's not much we can do about it. . .
I mean, it's been over three decades and it appears that Vampirella is still going strong. And I daresay it has nothing to do with fascinating storylines. . .
This entry was posted
on Friday, September 30, 2011
at Friday, September 30, 2011
. You can follow any responses to this entry through the
comments feed
.
Contributors
SFF Message Boards
Publishers
SFF Resources
Blog Archive
-
►
2012
(90)
-
►
February
(47)
- A Stark and Wormy Knight
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (February 2...
- Game of Thrones Season 2: First Look Trailer
- Exclusive extract from Melanie Rawn's TOUCHSTONE
- Mega-gamer package winners!
- The Making of the Otherland MMORPG
- Quote of the Day
- More inexpensive ebook goodies!
- Joe Abercrombie podcast
- Game of Thrones Season 2: Invitation to the Set
- 2011 Nebula Awards Nominees Announced
- Myke Cole contest winner!
- Musical Interlude
- More inexpensive ebook goodies!
- Game of Thrones Season 2: Working as an Extra
- Exclusive extract from Bradley P. Beaulieu's THE S...
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (February 1...
- Peter Watts vs Acrackedmoon
- Orb Sceptre Throne
- Saladin Ahmed contest winner!
- Game of Thrones Season 2: Notes From the Set: Icel...
- A bit of humor. . .
- Exclusive extract from David Constantine's THE PIL...
- Happy Valentine's Day!
- Deborah Harkness contest winner!
- Fantasy Writing Contest
- Musical Interlude
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (February 6...
- Win a copy of Mark Hodder's EXPEDITION TO THE MOUN...
- New US cover art for R. Scott Bakker's THE WHITE-L...
- Extract from Ari Marmell's THIEF'S COVENANT
- Author D&D Video Trailer
- More inexpensive ebook goodies!
- Kitty Goes to War
- Writing About Rape
- New The Amazing Spiderman Trailer
- Win a mega-gamer package from Tor Books!
- Wish I could. . .
- Saladin Ahmed has a new website!
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (January 30...
- A bit of humor. . .
- New artwork from the limited edition of Steven Eri...
- First synopsis for Joe Abercrombie's A RED COUNTRY...
- More inexpensive ebook goodies!
- Win a copy of Myke Cole's SHADOW OPS: CONTROL POIN...
- New Tad Williams novella
- Crucible of Gold
-
►
February
(47)
-
▼
2011
(611)
-
▼
September
(42)
- Cover art for Daniel Abraham's THE KING'S BLOOD an...
- Comic Book Sexuality
- Quote of the Day
- Martin Springett discusses the covers for Guy Gavr...
- Robin Hobb contest winner!
- Cover blurb for Ian Cameron Esslemont's ORB, SCEPT...
- Quote of the Day
- Game of Thrones Season 2 Teaser
- Musical Interlude
- Win a copy of Richard Morgan's THE COLD COMMANDS
- The Whisperer
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (September ...
- Game of Thrones in Muppet Form
- First set photos for Game of Thrones season 2
- Ode to a Bookstore Death
- Win a copy of David Anthony Durham's THE SACRED BA...
- Kafka on the Shore
- Peter Dinklage wins the Emmy!!!
- Cover art and blurb for Naomi Novik's CRUCIBLE OF ...
- I commend this one to your attention
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (September ...
- Quote of the Day
- Win a copy of SPECULATIVE HORIZONS edited by Patri...
- Jasper Kent contest winners!
- Musical Interlude
- The Absence of 9/11 from Science Fiction
- Cover art for the limited edition of Joe Abercromb...
- Video Q&A with C. S. Friedman
- Quote of the Day
- Win an Advance Reading Copy of Brandon Sanderson's...
- New Q&A with Scott Lynch
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (September ...
- New cover art for Ian Cameron Esslemont's ORB, SCE...
- THE SO MUCH LESS GAY and NOT WRITTEN WITH GAY BI...
- The Third Section
- Brian Ruckley contest winners!
- Extract from Bradley P. Beaulieu's THE WINDS OF KH...
- Musical Interlude
- Words of wisdom
- This week's New York Times Bestsellers (August 30t...
- What should I read next???
- Win a copy of the limited edition of Robin Hobb's ...
-
▼
September
(42)
Index of Reviews and Interviews
Fantasy Blogs of Interest
- A Dribble of Ink
- Blogorob
- Blood of the Muse
- Debuts and Reviews
- Fantasy Book Critic
- Fantasy/Scifi Book Review
- Graeme's Fantasy Book Reviews
- Grasping for the Wind
- Mysterious Outposts
- NextRead
- OF Blog of the Fallen
- Pyr-o-Mania
- Realms of Speculative Fiction
- Sandstorm Reviews
- Scifi Chick
- Speculative Fiction Junkie
- Speculative Horizons
- Speculative Reviews
- SQT Fantasy-Scifi Girl
- The Bodhisattva
- The Book Swede
- The Genre Files
- The Gravel Pit
- The Neth Space
- The Soulless Machine Review
- The Swivet
- The Wertzone
Speculative Fiction Authors
- Joe Abercrombie
- Daniel Abraham
- R. Scott Bakker
- Tobias S. Buckell
- Jacqueline Carey
- Stephen R. Donaldson
- Hal Duncan
- David Anthony Durham
- David Louis Edelman
- S. L. Farrell
- Raymond E. Feist
- C. S. Friedman
- Neil Gaiman
- Peter F. Hamilton
- Robin Hobb
- J. V. Jones
- Guy Gavriel Kay
- Paul Kearney
- Kay Kenyon
- Stephen King
- Katherine Kurtz
- Sergey Lukyanenko
- Scott Lynch
- George R. R. Martin
- GRRM's Not a Blog
- Ian McDonald
- L. E. Modesitt, jr.
- Richard Morgan
- Naomi Novik
- Terry Pratchett
- Melanie Rawn
- Alastair Reynolds
- Patrick Rothfuss
- Brian Ruckley
- Brandon Sanderson
- Ekaterina Sedia
- Joel Shepherd
- Dan Simmons
- Melinda Snodgrass
- Jeff Somers
- Neal Stephenson
- Carrie Vaughn
- Peter Watts
- Tad Williams
- Jack Whyte




